Research Article, Int J Cardiovasc Res Vol: 9 Issue: 5
Papillary Muscle Noncompaction: A Unique Mechanism for Mitral Regurgitation in Children
Sulafa KM Ali* and Laila M Elmahdi
Department of Pediatric Cardiology, Sudan Heart Center, University of Khartoum, Sudan
*Corresponding Author: Dr. Sulafa KM Ali
Consultant Pediatric Cardiologist at Sudan Heart Center. Professor, University of Khartoum, Sudan
E-mail: [email protected]
Received: July 21, 2020 Accepted: August 14, 2020 Published: August 20, 2020
Citation: Ali SKM, Elmahdi LM (2020) Papillary Muscle Noncompaction: A Unique Mechanism for Mitral Regurgitation in Children. Int J Cardiovasc Res 9:5. doi: 10.37532/icrj.2020.9(5).411
Background: Noncompaction Cardiomyopathy (NCCM) is a primary genetic cardiomyopathy with variable clinical and Echocardiographic (echo) features. Association with Mitral Regurgitation (MR) was reported but the mechanism of this association has not been well described in pediatric patients. Aims: To describe clinical and echo features of MR in NCCM. Methods: All pediatric patients with NCCM associated with MR and preserved ventricle function seen in one center from January 2015 to March 2020 were included. Clinical and echo features were described. Results: Twelve patients were identified (66% females), 8 (66%) presented with heart failure due to severe MR , and 4 were asymptomatic with mild-moderate MR. Echo features in all patients showed Papillary Muscle Noncompaction (PMNC). The Papillary Muscle (PM) base was discontinuous with the endocardium in 5 patients (41%) and PM were not well differentiated from the noncompacted myocardium in 3 patients (25%)There were variable degrees of chordal elongation and malcoaptation of the leaflets in all patients. Five patients (41%) had associated congenital heart disease including ventricular septal defects in 4 and patent ductus arteriosus in one patient. Conclusion: PMNC causes MV chordal abnormalities that lead to malcoaptation of the mitral leaflets resulting in MR. NCCM needs to be considered when evaluating patients with MR.
Keywords: Noncompaction cardiomyopathy; Mitral regurgitation; Echocardiography
NCCM is a Primary Genetic Cardiomyopathy (CMP) characterized by prominent myocardial trabeculations with deep intertrabecular recesses, readily identified by echocardiography (echo). It was initially described by histopathological studies in 1975 where it was referred to as “spongy myocardium” . In 1984, the first echo features of NCCM were described as “myocardial sinusoids”  and the term NCCM was first used in 1990 by Chin et al . Clinical features in children are heterogenous, some cases are asymptomatic, incidentally identified and others had severe heart failure and arrhythmias . The disease has familial occurrence in up to 30% of cases, different genes have been identified and there is a wide overlap with other types of CMP .
In 2004, we described the first series of patients with NCCM associated MR and preserved myocardial function . Subsequently, many other pediatric patients were reported by us describing the echo features which was characterized by PM affection [7,8].
In this report we report more pediatric cases with NCCM / MR and describe the echo features of PMNC which we believe is a unique mechanism for MR.
The study is retrospective and included all pediatric patients with NCCM associated with PM affection and MR seen from January 2015 to March 2020. The study protocol was approved by the hospital administration and ethics committee. Data on clinical and echo assessment (using Toshiba (Aplio) machine) were collected. Diagnosis of NCCM was based on the criteria of Jenni et al  using the following:
1. The appearance of a two-layer myocardium with multiple myocardial trabeculations and recesses.
2. The noncompacted to compacted layer thickness ratio measured from the parasternal short axis view during systole of >2:1.
MR was assessed using the American College of Cardiology Guidelines . We did not exclude patients with congenital heart disease.
We identified 12 patients with PMNC. Clinical and echo features are shown in (Table 1).
|Case No||Sex||Age||Clinical Features||Echo Features||Associations|
|1||F||9 years||NYHA 1||Moderate MR, PM base not continuous with the myocardium||Non|
|2||F||10 years||NYHA 4, for surgery||Sever MR, PM base not continuous with the myocardium. PM cannot be differentiated from myocardial trabeculations||Non|
|3||F||4 years||NYHA 4 , for surgery||Sever MR, ruptured chord, flail AML. PM base not continuous with the myocardium. PM cannot be differentiated from myocardial trabeculations||Non|
|4||F||12 years||NYHA 4 , for surgery||Sever, MR with severe malcoaptation. PM base not continuous with the myocardium||Non|
|5||M||2 years||Failure to thrive, heart failure, for surgery||Sever MR. PM base not continuous with the myocardium||Non|
|6||M||2 years||Asymptomatic||Moderate MR||Small muscular VSD|
|7||M||5 years||NYHA 1||Moderate MR||Non|
|8||F||2 years||Asymptomatic||Moderate MR
|9||F||16 months||Heart failure due to VSD||Moderate MR||Large sub arterial VSD|
|10||M||2 months||Heart failure due to patent ductus arteriosus, had surgical ligation of the ductus||Mild MR||Patent ductus arteriosus|
|11||F||8 months||Heart failure||Severe MR. PM cannot be differentiated from myocardial trabeculations||Large multiple muscular VSDs|
|12||F||12 years||NYHA 4, Not for surgery. Cardiac catheterization showed high pulmonary vascular resistance.||Severe MR. PM cannot be differentiated from myocardial trabeculations||Large multiple VSDs|
Table 1: Clinical and Echo Features of 12 Patients with PMNC.
The age ranged between 2 months and 12 years. Females were 66%. Clinical presentations include heart failure in 8 patients (66%), and a heart murmur without symptoms in 4 patients (33%). Echo features in all patients showed NCCM involving PM base. The PM base was discontinuous with the endocardium in 5 patients (41%) (Figures 1). The PM were not well differentiated from the noncompacted myocardium in 3 patients (25%) (Figure 2) There were variable degrees of chordal elongation /rupture. The mitral leaflets appear malcoapting in all patients (n). The anterior leaflet was more affected leading to variable degrees of superior displacement of the leaflet tip and in one case it was flail. MR was severe in 6 patients (50%), moderate in 5 (41%) and mild in 1 patient. Ejection fraction was normal>55% in all 12 patients. Associated congenital heart disease were found in 5 patients (41%) including Ventricular Septal Defects (VSD) in 4 (2 of them had multiple VSDs) and patent ductus arteriosus in one patient.
The mechanism of MR in NCCM can be related to mitral valve annular dilatation secondary to left ventricle dysfunction, however in patients with normal ejection fraction, the mechanism of MR is more likely to be related to PM affection, as shown in this case series. As has been observed by us and others, the PMNC leads to elongation/rupture of chordae resulting in variable degrees of leaflet malcoaptation [6,11]. Chordal rupture has been confirmed by intraoperative inspection where the PM base was found to be friable prohibiting MV repair .
Other authors observed the lack of coaptation of the MV in NCCM, however, the causal relation with PMNC has not been emphasized . Coaptation abnormalities might be similar to MV prolapse, many authors in fact, described “mitral valve prolapse” association with NCCM [14,15]. On the other hand, there had been reports about the frequency of CMP in patients with MV prolapse in the absence of MR. Some patients in these series showed left ventricle dilatation or abnormal systolic or diastolic dysfunction . 1n this latter report, the cases shown had trabeculated left ventricle myocardium, though this was not pointed out by the authors. We believe that in this subset of patients with “MV prolapse”, NCCM needs to be considered and ruled out as the MV abnormalities could mimic those seen in PMNC as both conditions can lead to chordal elongation/rupture.
The most compelling evidence of PMNC came from Badhwar who initially reported a case of NCCM with severe MR who underwent MV surgery and later had sustainable improvement of ejection fraction . On intraoperative inspection, similar to our patients, the author found that the usual PM and their chordal continuity were absent and multiple PM-like structures, attached to the MV leaflets by thin chords were seen. According to the author, these findings could impact on surgical techniques such as PM repositioning or neo-chord reconstruction.
Cardiac magnetic resonance imaging has been helpful in delineating the PM affection in NCCM and showed that the total PM area in patients with NCCM was lower than controls .
As NCCM has a guarded prognosis due to later onset of heart failure, arrhythmias and thrombo-embolism, PM dysfunction related to NCCM should carefully be looked for when evaluating patients with MR in order to plan patient management and counselling.
We described a distinct entity: PMNC that has characteristic echo features leading to leaflet coaptation abnormalities. PMNC has important implications on patient management and prognosis.
- Dusek J, Ostadal B, Duskova M (1975) Postnatal persistence of spongy myocardium with embryonic blood supply. Arch Pathol 6: 312-317.
- Engberding R, Bender F (1984) Identification of a rare congenital anomaly of the myocardium by two-dimensional echocardiography: persistence of isolated myocardial sinusoids. Am J Cardiol 11: 1733-1734.
- Chin TK, Perloff JK, Williams RG, Jue K, Mohrmann R, et al. (1990) Isolated noncompaction of left ventricular myocardium a study of eight cases. Circulation 8: 508-513
- Sulafa KM, Godman MJ (2004) The variable clinical presentation of and outcome for noncompaction of the ventricular myocardium in infants and children, an under-diagnosed cardiomyopathy. Cardiol Young; 14: 409-416.
- Bhatia NL, Tajik AJ, Wilansky S, Steidley DE, Mookadam F, et al. (2011) Isolated noncompaction of the left ventricular myocardium in adults: a systematic overview. Journal of Cardiac Failure 17: 771-778.
- Sulafa KM, Omran AS, Najm HK, Godman MJ (2004) Noncompaction of ventricular myocardium with mitral regurgitation and preserved ventricular function. Journal of the American Society of Echocardiography 17: 87-90.
- Sulafa KM (2008) Unique features of noncompaction in Arab and African patients. Cardiovasc J Afr 19: 195-199.
- Sulafa KM, Abu-Sulaiman R, Agouba RB (2015) Noncompaction cardiomyopathy: A new mechanism for mitral regurgitation with distinct clinical, echocardiographic features and pathological correlations. J Saudi Heart Assoc. 27: 71-78.
- Jenni R, Oechslin E, Schneider J, Jost CA, Kaufmann PA, et al. (2011) Echocardiographic and pathoanatomical characteristics of isolated left ventricular non-compaction: a step towards classification as a distinct cardiomyopathy. Heart 86: 666–671.
- Zoghbi WA, Enriquez-Sarano M, Foster E, Grayburn PA, Kraft CD, et al. (2003) Recommendations for evaluation of the severity of native valvular regurgitation with twodimensional and doppler echocardiography. J Am Soc Echocardiogr. 16: 777-802.
- Lan J, Mingxing X, Xinfang W, Li Y, Xiaofang L, et al. (2010) Echocardiographic characteristics of left ventricle noncompaction with papillary muscle involvement. Heart 96: A213-A214.
- Chung JW, Lee SJ, Lee JH, Chin JY, Lee HJ, et al. (2009) Isolated left ventricular noncompaction cardiomyopathy accompanied by severe mitral regurgitation. Korean Circ J 39: 494-498.
- Nikolaos K, Ioanna K, Ioanna X, George H, Dimitrios A, et al. (2015) Lack of mitral valve leaflet coaptation in a case of non-compaction cardiomyopathy. Int J Cardio 187: 272
- Fonseca P, Sampaio F, Ferreira N, Gonçalves H, Ribeiro VG, et al. (2016) A familial cluster of left ventricular non-compaction and mitral valve prolapse. Eur Heart J Cardiovasc Imaging 17: 153.
- Igarashi T, Takase S, Satokawa H, Wakamatsu H, Kurosawa H, et al. (2013) Left ventricular noncompaction complicated by mitral valve prolapse: report of a case. Surg Today 43: 818-820.
- Jost CA, Greutmann M, Connolly HM, Naegeli B, Faeh-Gunz A, et al. (2015) Left ventricular cardiomyopathy in mitral valve prolapse: fact or fiction?. EMJ Cardiol 3: 30-37.
- George KM, Badhwar V (2010) Sustainable myocardial recovery after mitral reconstruction for left ventricular noncompaction. Ann Thorac Surg 89: 1283-1284.
- Stacey RB, Haag J, Hall ME, McLeod G, Upadhya B, et al. (2014) Mitral regurgitation in left ventricular noncompaction cardiomyopathy assessed by cardiac MRI. J Heart Valve Dis 23: 591-597.